Firm or Plush Mattress: Which Is Right for You?
How well you sleep depends a great deal on the mattress you choose. If you often wake up with muscle soreness or feel like you barely slept, your mattress may not be providing the proper support. The firmness or plushness of your mattress allows your muscles to relax fully, based on your preferred sleep position, injuries, and whether you sleep with a partner.
What Determines if a Mattress Is Firm or Plush?
The firmness of a mattress is determined by its construction and materials. Firm mattresses provide an even and sturdy surface, even if they have a layer of pillow top for comfort. Plush mattresses have thicker comfort layers that offer ample cushioning for that “hug” feeling when you lie down.
Keep in mind that you don't have to choose between an extra firm or ultra plush mattress. There are plush mattresses with the support of a firm mattress and firm mattresses with plenty of plush on the top layer. Many of our hybrid mattresses combine the best of both firm support and plush cushioning.
We can help you learn whether a plush or firm mattress – or something in between – is right for you. Our bedMATCH® system is scientifically designed to help you find the right level of comfort. You can also visit any Mattress Warehouse store to speak with a professional and try out our wide selection of mattresses.
Are Firm or Plush Mattresses Better?
Not all mattresses are designed with the same level of firmness or plushness – what some call “softness.” Choosing the level that's right for you will depend on a few factors.
Sleeping Position
Your sleep position influences what level of firmness or plushness you find most comfortable. Stomach and back sleepers usually need a firmer mattress to keep their spines aligned, while side sleepers often prefer a plusher mattress that cradles the hips and keeps the spine in alignment.
Partner Preferences
Many plush mattresses are designed to absorb motion. If you sleep with a partner, this can help you avoid waking each other when moving or getting in and out of bed. If you prefer a firm mattress and your partner prefers something plusher, hybrid options or medium-firm models can be a great compromise.
Pain Points
Living with chronic pain can affect your sleep. Whether you need a plush or firm mattress, consider the parts of your body that experience the most pain. For example, those with back problems might find that a plush mattress pulls their spine out of alignment, while those with shoulder pain may find relief from an ultra-plush mattress that cushions sore joints.
When Should You Choose a Plush Mattress?
Plush mattresses offer luxurious cushioning—a gentle “hug” for your body. Side sleepers benefit from the extra give around hips and shoulders, which helps maintain spinal alignment. Plush mattresses also reduce motion transfer, making them ideal for couples or light sleepers.
When Should You Choose a Firm Mattress?
A firm mattress provides essential support, especially for back and stomach sleepers who need to maintain proper spinal alignment. Firm surfaces also offer a bit more “bounce,” which some people prefer for mobility or support reasons.
What Can I Do if My Mattress Is Too Plush or Too Firm?
If your current mattress feels too firm or too plush, there are ways to adjust the comfort level without immediately buying a new one. However, these are temporary fixes—investing in the right mattress is always the best long-term solution.
How to Make Your Mattress Firmer
- Add a firm, supportive mattress topper.
- Add a bunkie board under your mattress.
- Use a box spring if you don’t already have one.
How to Make Your Mattress Plusher
- Add a plush, cushioning mattress topper .
- Replace your bed frame with one that has more give, such as a base with sprung wooden slats.
- If you have a memory foam mattress , consider making your bedroom warmer—memory foam softens slightly in warmer temperatures.
Find the Perfect Level of Comfort at Mattress Warehouse
Whether you prefer firm support or crave ultra-plush comfort, Mattress Warehouse has the perfect mattress for you. Use our bedMATCH® system to discover the ideal firmness level for your body.
Visit one of our many convenient locations to try our mattresses for yourself! Our Sleep Professionals are ready to help you find the mattress of your dreams.
